The Maxthon Alternative »
It seems like a number of people are talking about the Maxthon browser in the last couple of days. At a glance, the features look to be okay. So naturally, I decided to try it out.
The download, installation, startup and even browsing speed are good. Very quick in every respect. Probably even better than Firefox in most. So I moved on to usability.
I like the tab browsing. In fact, the default tab controls in Maxthon appear to be even better than those in Firefox. Not that those in Firefox are bad - just that the controls in Maxthon are... impressive. Would I use them? I don't think so. But it's a big list, nonetheless, and some people like having something bigger than the other guy.
In fact, that's the impression I'm left with after trying Maxthon for a bit. This thing has options like you would not believe, and it also appears to support a form of extension with add-ons. That's really cool, and I may look at it in more detail. But for now, there is just so much to it that I find it overwhelming.
Especially because I didn't care for the basic browsing experience. I think their implementation is decent, but there were so many things that I couldn't figure out, and the options that might control what I need to do are so huge, I just decided to leave it be for right now.
A couple of peeves did come to light immediately. I was unable to drag and drop anything - even from the address bar to the bookmark bar within Maxthon. I can understand (perhaps) not being able to drag from Firefox, but within the browser itself?
I also was unable to figure out how to have as much tab control as with Firefox. I like being able to middle-click and open new links in a new tab. I can turn on all links to open in new tabs in Maxthon, but then they open in the background and I have to select them.
Finally, the popup blocking doesn't work as well as it does with Firefox. The very first page I visited had a popup that was not blocked by Maxthon, even though I had turned on all the popup-blocking functions that I could find.
In the end, it just didn't feel as comfortable as Firefox. But I'll keep my eyes on it. The browser does hold promise - it just strikes me that perhaps they are trying to do too much, to be all things to all people. Maybe I'm in the minority, but Firefox fits the bill for me just fine.
Update: On a related note, the only thing that bugs me about Firefox is that it doesn't do a particularly good job about blocking "floater" ads. The ones that walk, drop or slide across the screen. I think these are Flash-based, but I'm not certain. And I don't know that Maxthon blocks them either. But if I could get Firefox to do that, I'd be joyous. Anyone know of anything that will work against these bad boys?
Update: At least some are Javascript-based, and disabling Javascript will take care of the problem. The issue with that is that some Javascript is okay. The formatting buttons I use while composing this entry, for example. Perhaps just disabling the window.onload event would do it.
